2003/2004 school year
A feasibility study was prepared to look at ways the six Catholic urban schools of Indianapolis could share financial resources, personnel, and be positively supported by a central office.
2004/2005 school year
A transition year from six autonomous schools under the direction of each parish was transitioned to a Consortium model with the accountability and the oversight of the schools being moved to the Catholic Urban School Consortium office.
2005/2006 school year
The Catholic Urban School Consortium began full implementation, oversight, and support to the six (6) schools.
May 27, 2006
The Board of Trustees of Catholic Urban School Consortium held their first meeting with Tony Watt as chairperson.
2006/2007 school year
This year saw the beginning of the Board limited jurisdiction.
The six schools included All Saints, Holy Cross, St. Philip Neri, Central Catholic, St. Andrew/St. Rita, and Holy Angels.
All Saints School location was too large for the community and therefore was moved back to the grounds located at St. Anthony and renamed St. Anthony School. The Catholic Urban School Consortium officially was named Mother Theodore Catholic Academies.
Research on a charter school concept began.
Charter School application to the Marion County Charter School was submitted for consideration for St. Andrew/St. Rita and St. Anthony.
Final approval of the charter application was received to transform St. Andrew/St. Rita to Andrew Academy and St. Anthony to Padua Academy.
2010/2011 school year
Mother Theodore Catholic Academies continued with the oversight of the 4 Catholic Schools. At the same time MTCA was contracted by the ADI Schools, Inc. to oversee the operations of Andrew Academy (previously St. Andrew/St. Rita) and Padua Academy (previously St. Anthony). These two schools are mayor sponsored public charter schools.